The University of Georgia
GAES Research Report Number 657
November 1998
INSECT SCREENING RESULTS
Evaluation of Corn Hybrids
for Resistance to Insects
N. W. Widstrom
Environmental conditions in Georgia are normally favorable for buildup of insect populations large enough to cause serious damage to corn. Generally, this damage is greatest in late-planted corn left in the field for an extended period past maturity.
Hybrids resistant to insects are recommended for planting and are presently the only economical means, in late plantings, for the reduction of damage by corn earworm, fall armyworm, maize weevil, and pink scavenger caterpillar. Consult your local county agent and/or extension entomologist for additional control recommendations for other insects.
Percent yield losses attributable to all insects for individual hybrids varied from 2.3% to 9.6% and are reflected by VG, G, F, P, and VP ratings in the tables. Hybrids in the three tests sustained average yield losses of 6.0%, 6.1%, and 5.0% in the preliminary and full-season, mid-season, and short-season hybrid tests, respectively. The mean level of overall yield loss for all tests was 6.1%. Of the total loss, about 44% was attributable to ear injury by the corn earworm, 47% to the pink scavenger caterpillar, and 9% to the maize weevil. Losses to the pink scavenger caterpillar and maize weevil are based on damage by multiple generations of these insects as the corn dries in the field. Timely harvest will substantially reduce losses to these two insects.
Evaluations for resistance to corn earworm and fall armyworm, maize weevil, and pink scavenger caterpillar are given for hybrids in the tables following. Lettered ratings refer only to relative resistance to insects and are not indicative of yield. Thus, a hybrid rated poor for resistance to insects might possibly be among the highest yielders and vice-versa. See the yield data in other tables for this information.
Husk tightness ratings were assigned using a scale of 1 to 5, in which 1 = very loose and 5 = very tight. No average rating was less than 2.0 or greater than 4.0; therefore, only loose, medium, and tight ratings are given in the tables.
Each of the three tests of hybrids (preliminary and full-season, mid-season, and short-season) was planted April 23, 1998. Plots were thinned to 20,000 plants per acre. Ratings for overall insect damage were completed during September.
Data for this section were compiled by J. M. Cook and J. C. Mullis of the United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Insect Biology and Population Management Research Laboratory, and Georgia Coastal Plain Experiment Station, Tifton, Georgia.
Tifton, Georgia: |
|||||
Short-Season Corn Hybrids, 1998 |
|||||
Evaluations for Resistance to Insects and Other Traits |
|||||
| Overall Resistance to insect injury2 |
|||||
| Company or Brand Name |
Hybrid Name |
Husk Tightness1 |
Days to Anthesis | 1998 | 2 or more years |
| Funk's G | 5510-A | M | 56 | VG | G |
| Garst | 8222IT | M | 55 | G | - |
| Pioneer | 3245 | M | 56 | G | G |
| Pioneer | 3223 | T | 58 | G | F |
| HyPerformer | HS9843 | M | 57 | G | G |
| Gutwein | 2696 | L | 58 | G | F |
| Pioneer | 32k61 | M | 55 | G | G |
| Funk's G | 5516 | T | 57 | G | G |
| NK | N7931 | M | 56 | G | F |
| Terra | TR1154 | T | 55 | F | F |
| DeKalb | DK668 | T | 58 | F | F |
| Grabow | 71593TC-S | M | ms | F | - |
| NK | N73-N8 | M | 56 | F | - |
| Grabow | 71593 | M | 57 | F | - |
| AgraTech | 787 | M | 58 | F | F |
| AgraTech | ATX770 | M | 56 | F | F |
| Funk's G | 4581 | M | 57 | F | F |
| Grabow | 71611TC3-S | M | ms | F | - |
| NK | N7931 | M | 56 | F | - |
| Garst | N5254 | L | 58 | F | - |
| HyPerformer | HY9646 | M | 56 | F | P |
| AgriPro | AP9707 | M | 57 | P | P |
| Garst | 8396IT | M | 55 | P | - |
| Southland | SS-5111 | M | 58 | P | - |
| NK | N79-P4 | L | 55 | P | - |
| Asgrow | RX913 | M | 58 | P | - |
| AgraTech | ATX721 | L | 56 | VP | P |
| Pioneer | 33G26 | L | 54 | VP | - |
| Southland | SS-4115 | M | 56 | VP | - |
| HyPerformer | HY9646 | L | 72 | P | - |
| 1. L = loose husks, M = medium-tight husks, T = tight husks. | |||||
| 2. Overall resistance to insect injury evaluations were made on the basis of total percent damage to the ear by one or more of the following insect categories: corn earworm and fall armyworm, maize weevil, and pink scavenger caterpillar. Ratings were made on a scale from very good to very poor, where VG = very good, G = good, F = fair, P = poor, and VP = very poor. | |||||
Tifton, Georgia: |
|||||
Mid-Season Corn Hybrids, 1998 |
|||||
Evaluations for Resistance to Insects and Other Traits |
|||||
| Overall Resistance to insect injury2 |
|||||
| Company or Brand Name |
Hybrid Name |
Husk Tightness1 |
Days to Anthesis | 1998 | 2 or more years |
| NK | N8811 | M | 56 | VG | VG |
| DeKalb | DK706 | M | 56 | G | G |
| Pioneer | 31B13 | M | 58 | G | G |
| Pioneer | 3146 | T | 57 | G | G |
| Pioneer | 3245S | M | 61 | G | - |
| NK | N83-N5 | M | 58 | G | - |
| Pioneer | 3167 | M | 58 | G | G |
| Terra | TR1186 | M | 55 | G | F |
| Terra | TR1185 | L | 56 | F | F |
| Mycogen | 8460 | L | 58 | F | F |
| DeKalb | DK687 | T | 56 | F | G |
| NK | N83-R7 | L | 56 | F | F |
| Terra | TR702E | M | 58 | F | G |
| Pioneer | 3163 | M | 56 | F | F |
| Terra | TR 1167 | M | 57 | F | F |
| AgriPro | AP9939 | M | 57 | F | - |
| DeKalb | DK683 | M | 56 | F | G |
| Vigoro | V5970 | M | 58 | F | - |
| Mycogen | 2815 | M | 56 | F | F |
| Southland | SS-5119 | M | 60 | F | F |
| AgriPro | AP9909 | M | 58 | P | P |
| Southland | SS4120 | M | 57 | P | P |
| Mycogen | 2888 | M | 57 | P | P |
| DeKalb | DK679 | M | 58 | VP | - |
| Pioneer | 31G20 | M | 55 | VP | P |
| 1. L = loose husks, M = medium-tight husks, T = tight husks. | |||||
| 2. Overall resistance to insect injury evaluations were made on the basis of total percent damage to the ear by one or more of the following insect categories: corn earworm and fall armyworm, maize weevil, and pink scavenger caterpillar. Ratings were made on a scale from very good to very poor, where VG = very good, G = good, F = fair, P = poor, and VP = very poor. | |||||
Tifton, Georgia: |
|||||
Preliminary and Full-Season Corn Hybrids, 1998 |
|||||
Evaluations for Resistance to Insects and Other Traits |
|||||
| Overall Resistance to insect injury2 |
|||||
| Company or Brand Name |
Hybrid Name |
Husk Tightness1 |
Days to Anthesis | 1998 | 2 or more years |
| Greenwood | 845 | T | 62 | VG | - |
| Wilson | E7005 | M | 57 | VG | - |
| Asgrow | XP8897 | M | 55 | VG | - |
| Greenwood | 760 | M | 56 | VG | - |
| Southland | SS8136* | M | 62 | VG | - |
| Galilee | GIS982 | T | 59 | G | - |
| Wilson | E3056 | M | 55 | G | - |
| Terra | E1188 | L | 56 | G | - |
| Grabow | 81570 | M | 56 | G | - |
| Southland | EXP1498214 | L | 57 | F | - |
| Wilson | E8051 | M | 57 | F | - |
| AgriPro | AP9828 | L | 57 | F | - |
| AgriPro | AP9829IMI | L | 56 | F | - |
| Pioneer | 3085* | M | 57 | F | G |
| Grabow | 81601 | L | 56 | P | - |
| Mycogen | 2725 | L | 55 | P | P |
| Galilee | GIS1007 | M | 58 | P | - |
| Southland | EXP1497111 | M | 58 | P | P |
| Southland | EXP1498116 | L | 56 | P | - |
| Wilson | E5307 | M | 56 | P | - |
| Asgrow | RX813 | L | 55 | P | - |
| Grabow | 81581 | L | 55 | P | - |
| Grabow | 81585 | L | 55 | VP | - |
| Asgrow | RX810 | L | 55 | VP | - |
| 1. L = loose husks, M = medium-tight husks, T = tight husks. | |||||
| 2. Overall resistance to insect injury evaluations were made on the basis of total percent damage to the ear by one or more of the following insect categories: corn earworm and fall armyworm, maize weevil, and pink scavenger caterpillar. Ratings were made on a scale from very good to very poor, where VG = very good, G = good, F = fair, P = poor, and VP = very poor. | |||||
| * Full-season hybrid. | |||||